Status
The parametric non-distinguishing half is DONE — proofs/agda/EchoEntropy.agda ships entropy-blind-parametric (any H : (Fin 2 → W) → X factoring through the fibre distribution agrees on echo-true vs echo-false) and entropy-witness-distinguishes (the Σ-witness distinguishes), landed in #261. The discrete fibre-count shadow (entropy-shadow / shannon-shadow via ⌊log₂⌋) was already present.
Open
Lift the shadow to real-valued H(P) = −Σ pᵢ log pᵢ over a parametric distribution. This needs a rationals/reals layer + a probability interface — out of reach under --safe --without-K without significant extra infrastructure. Lower priority: the discrete + parametric forms are the load-bearing artifacts for the abstraction-barrier line.
In-repo sketch / proof-debt (already recorded)
proofs/agda/EchoEntropy.agda companion-remark: the open real-valued / mutual-information forms.
EchoThermodynamics.agda and EchoStabilityTests.agda point at EchoEntropy.agda.
Acceptance
Status
The parametric non-distinguishing half is DONE —
proofs/agda/EchoEntropy.agdashipsentropy-blind-parametric(anyH : (Fin 2 → W) → Xfactoring through the fibre distribution agrees onecho-truevsecho-false) andentropy-witness-distinguishes(the Σ-witness distinguishes), landed in #261. The discrete fibre-count shadow (entropy-shadow/shannon-shadowvia⌊log₂⌋) was already present.Open
Lift the shadow to real-valued
H(P) = −Σ pᵢ log pᵢover a parametric distribution. This needs a rationals/reals layer + a probability interface — out of reach under--safe --without-Kwithout significant extra infrastructure. Lower priority: the discrete + parametric forms are the load-bearing artifacts for the abstraction-barrier line.In-repo sketch / proof-debt (already recorded)
proofs/agda/EchoEntropy.agdacompanion-remark: the open real-valued / mutual-information forms.EchoThermodynamics.agdaandEchoStabilityTests.agdapoint atEchoEntropy.agda.Acceptance
--safe-compatible reals / probability interface (or an explicitly isolated + justified analytic interface).Hdefined; the non-distinguishing theorem restated overH.