Summary
A newly created OpenShell sandbox can be reported Ready before its labeled Podman-backed container is visible to NemoClaw's privileged Docker control path. Hermes post-onboarding then exhausts the current 30-second managed-control settlement window with PRIVILEGED_CONTROL_UNAVAILABLE, even though the sandbox becomes healthy shortly afterward.
Evidence
- Reproduced by GFN Build 346 with candidate
e6d435819bc7c4a5c07860665c5712173f6e47a9.
- Sandbox creation, authenticated Hermes health, dashboard, and inference-route checks succeeded.
- The immediate privileged secret-boundary recovery returned only the exact sanitized
PRIVILEGED_CONTROL_UNAVAILABLE startup marker.
- A later explicit probe found and reused the same healthy container; no Podman restart or container recreation was required.
- Forward recovery then could not establish the required host forwards, including port 8642, because onboarding had advanced past the unsettled privileged-control phase.
Required behavior
- Keep the happy path unchanged.
- Treat only the exact, sanitized
PRIVILEGED_CONTROL_UNAVAILABLE result as a transient startup observation.
- Extend the bounded post-create settlement window enough for the observed OpenShell Ready-to-container-discovery handoff.
- Continue to fail immediately on identity, integrity, malformed-output, ambiguous-container, or diagnostic-bearing failures.
- Add regression coverage proving settlement can succeed after the former bound and that diagnostic-bearing failures remain terminal.
- Run focused managed-startup/process-recovery tests and PR validation.
Security constraints
- Do not accept process presence as proof of sandbox identity.
- Do not relax immutable container identity pinning.
- Do not retry diagnostics that contain anything beyond the exact approved startup marker.
- Do not emit credentials or unsanitized runtime output.
Summary
A newly created OpenShell sandbox can be reported Ready before its labeled Podman-backed container is visible to NemoClaw's privileged Docker control path. Hermes post-onboarding then exhausts the current 30-second managed-control settlement window with
PRIVILEGED_CONTROL_UNAVAILABLE, even though the sandbox becomes healthy shortly afterward.Evidence
e6d435819bc7c4a5c07860665c5712173f6e47a9.PRIVILEGED_CONTROL_UNAVAILABLEstartup marker.Required behavior
PRIVILEGED_CONTROL_UNAVAILABLEresult as a transient startup observation.Security constraints